Islamorada
Sport-fishing capital — walkable villages on both sides of US-1.
Six connected islands with the strongest sport-fishing identity in the Keys. Islamorada trades raw acreage for refined waterfront neighborhoods and a more polished restaurant and retail scene.
Premium coastal village — sport-fishing charters, high-end dining, galleries, beach clubs. Quieter and more curated than Key West.
Second-home and lifestyle buyers who want concierge-level village life, anglers, and families wanting a walkable waterfront base.
Ocean-front estates, bay-side pool homes, canal-front homes in Plantation Key and Lower Matecumbe, and some condo/townhome product.
Both oceanfront and bayfront lots command premium. Deepwater dockage and protected basins (e.g., Port Antigua) are the differentiators.
Consistently among the highest price-per-square-foot markets in the Keys outside Ocean Reef.
Islamorada FAQ
- What's the vacation-rental outlook in Islamorada?
- Short-term rentals are restricted in most of Islamorada; 28-day minimums are common. Always confirm with Village of Islamorada before underwriting a rental-income purchase.
Talk to Gracie
Serious about Islamorada?
Gracie will hand-curate Islamorada listings matching your criteria, walk you through the VR rules and insurance math, and set up showings when you're ready.